ICSC Director: Extreme weather is not result of greenhouse gas emissions
To the editor:
The scientists signing the Iowa Climate Statement are hugely overconfident in their assertions that we are headed for dangerous global warming and worsening drought. Considering the sun is thought to be entering its weakest cycles in 150 years, we may very well be in for global cooling, not warming; no one knows.
Contrary to popular opinion, the intensity and frequency of extreme weather events are not affected by our emissions of greenhouse gases, even if those emissions cause global warming. The 2011 Nongovernmental International Panel on Climate Change report (NIPCC – see www.nipccreport.com) concluded “…the data reveal there have not been any significant warming-induced increases in extreme weather events.”
This was the case whether the phenomenon studied was precipitation, floods, drought, storms, hurricanes, fire, or other weather-related events. NIPCC author, Dr. Madhav Khandekar, demonstrated that extreme weather events are now occurring with about the same frequency as they did during 1945-1977 cooling period.
To see if extremes are really on the rise, we must consult the National Climatic Data Center. We find that most records were set many decades ago. Here* are the state-wide extreme weather records for Iowa:
Highest temperature: 1934
Lowest temperature: 1912 and 1996
Most precipitation in a 24 hour period: 1998
Most snowfall in a 24 hour period: 1918
Greatest snow depth: 1969
Since we have no chance of stopping warming, cooling or extreme weather events, we need to better prepare for such inevitable climate variability.
Tom Harris, Director
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada